Water Snakes and Migration (Post #8)
I will start off this post by saying migration from a large continent to an island has a much bigger effect on the allele frequency of the island because of the smaller population size in proportion to the continent. For the opposite migration, from the island to the continent, there is not a significant impact on allele frequencies due to it just being one or a few individuals now in this larger population of organisms. This is the dilution effect. And now with this information, I will continue on to the data about the water snakes.
Based on the data from the graphs, it can be assumed that the snakes that are currently on the islands originally migrated from the Ohio side of the lake, and not Ontario. This is because there are no allele frequencies of the less striped snakes in Ontario, which shows that snakes have not and can not get to or from there from the islands. The other mainland location, the Peninsular mainland in Ohio, also has a large frequency of allele D, which is the most striped variation of the snake. However, it also has small frequencies of alleles A, B, and C. This shows that when the snakes had migrated onto the islands and evolved, some eventually migrated back onto the mainland in Ohio, or that they evolved on the mainland before moving to the islands, (although I think the first theory is the case). Since the alleles migrating onto a mainland don't have a large affect on the population already there, the frequencies remain relatively low. In the island graphs, we can see that the frequency of the D allele goes significantly down, which shows that color morph was not beneficial to those individuals. This is why the snakes would have evolved and the newer, less striped individuals would survive and reproduce better. On the graphs, another thing I noticed was that the further away from the Ohio peninsula the snakes are, the higher frequency of allele A they have. Also, the fewer frequency of allele D. I suspect that since the snakes with the D alleles don't do so well on the islands, it is hard for them to make it all the way out to the farthest ones from the mainland, so fewer are there. Also, the islands closest to the mainland may have similarities to it in environment and habitat, so some snakes of all the different allele variations are able to survive there. As you work farther one way or the other, I think that the habitat becomes more distinct, so there is one type of snake that really thrives there. That could be why the frequency of alleles shifts from D to A as you go from mainland to the farthest island group. Also, I am not sure if the snakes are able to swim from the islands to the mainland, which would affect the allele frequencies per island as they moved. If this is the case, it could explain why all four alleles are found on all of the islands and the peninsula and why the snakes have not evolved to just the best allele for that island. Also, I think time needs to be taken into account because maybe the snakes have not had time to fully evolve and habitate different islands to their fullest extent.
Hi Sarah!
ReplyDeleteI agree with your theory that the snakes on the island most likely migrated from the Ohio side of the lake because there are no instances of a snake with any other allele than the D allele on the Ontario side of the lake. In order for these Alleles to show up later in a population, they must have at least had some ancestors with that allele.
Hi Sarah! I think you did a great job explaining the data and putting it into words that we can all make sense of. I like how you questioned things at the end that could have potentially altered the outcome and considered things beyond just the data and what was given to us.
ReplyDeleteSarah,
ReplyDeleteGreat post! Your interpretation of the graphs is very detailed and well thought out. I like how you talked about the distance between the islands in relation to the phenotypic ratio and how it could have occurred due to the distance.