Lamarkism (Post #4)

Jean Baptiste Lamarck was one of the first naturalists to conceptualize the theory of evolution. However, his theory differs greatly from Darwin's and that of today. 


1. How does Lamarck's view of evolution differ from our current understanding?

           Lamarck saw evolution as a way that animals could change to help themselves in the 'now'. One of his most famous theories was how giraffes stretched their necks. His main view on how organisms change was through 'use' and 'disuse'. As we know now, it doesn't matter how much or little an organism uses something, it is about the traits from the successful organisms that get passed on to the next generation. He also believed that organisms evolved always from simple to more complex, and kept going and giving us new life on earth. However, we don't believe that is the truth in all cases, today.

2. What aspects did he get right, and what did he get wrong?

         Lamarck believed that giraffes' necks grew to reach the leaves high up in the trees, where no other animal could reach. Which, over time, they did. However, it is his belief that animals could change in their lifetime, and their offspring would inherit that particular change that was off. Lamarck also believed that in order to survive to a changing environment, the animal itself had to change. I suppose that an animal could change its behavior to give it a better chance at survival, but we now know that animals can't spontaneously change to suit their needs. It takes many generations, in most cases, for a species to show a collective change in their genome. In addition to that, an animal changes not to suit their environment better personally, but because of natural selection. That is the key point that Lamarck was missing. Animals weren't changing on the spot to better themselves, the animals that were more equipped for that particular environment would survive to produce offspring with that same well-adapted trait. Another misconception that Lamarck had was that organisms would continuously evolve into more and more complex organisms. However, I think that would be completely impossible, because every organism has its niche and place in the world. What would all of the whales do if krill kept evolving into more of a large lobster-like creature? It would mess up the whole food chain. I agree that the more complex animals had to start out as more simple organisms and evolve, but not every simple organism is going to evolve into something more complex. However, after all the things Lamarck was 'off' about, he gave us the idea of evolution and that species changed over time. He was a very important naturalist, and many scientists who came after him, like Darwin, greatly benefitted from his work.

Comments

  1. I liked the point you made about how each organism has a special place in the food chain. It takes all kinds to make the world go 'round! You are absolutely right about how change is driven by suitability to environment -- not "betterment" of the organism. One example that shows this is how snakes had legs at one point, and then eventually lost them. They didn't need to be more complex in order to be better at surviving in their environment. Lamarck's theories opened the doors for some very important discussions about evolution.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Kathleen! I hadn't really thought about the food chain being involved until I sat down to write this post, haha. I really like your snake example, too! They obviously didn't need to keep getting more complex in order to survive. It just so happened that they got a little simpler, instead!

      Delete
  2. I love how organized your blogs are! I also like how you mentioned here that one of the key flaws in Lamarck's theory was that organisms evolve into more complex organisms. Sometimes this is true, but you can't count on it as a general rule. I also think it's important to note, like you said, that while Lamarck was wrong about a lot of things, his theories were important because other people were able to build off of his work. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Sarah! I agree with Ally that your blog is super organized! I love it! I'm glad you brought attention to Lamarck's idea that organisms would change on an individual level to adjust to changes in their environments, because we know now that this is definitely not the case, and even if an organism is able to adapt in behavioral ways, this is not what we would consider evolution today. I also like that you highlighted Lamarck's misconception that organisms become "more complex" over time-all organisms that are alive and present today are just as evolved as any other organism alive today! Great ideas here!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I also mentioned giraffes in my Lamarck post. It was a great thought that he had, but not quite on par with what was going on. His complexity theory makes me laugh a little bit as well. We have vestigial structures, so if those no longer server a purpose, wouldn't that be a step in the opposite direction?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Darwin's Descent With Modification (Post #3)

Natural Selection and Evolution (Post #6)