Evolution Basic Questions (Post #2)
Basic Questions of Evolution
What is evolution? (In my own words):
I think that evolution is the gradual change of species or organisms over time in response to their environment and its stimuli, which is heavily influenced or caused by natural selection. After learning about evolution since I was in middle school, I would like to think that I have a good idea as to what it is. However, I know it is much more complex than it seems. I definitely know that evolution is about change, and you can see how different organisms are linked throughout diagrams and trees. Fossils and other remains have been some of the main reasons scientists can see evolution without it happening in front of them. Also, you can see it beginning in speciation, like in the Galapagos with the finches. I also know that natural selection is a very large part of evolution. Without it, organisms would have no real reason to need to evolve. Natural selection makes sure that the 'fittest' survive and reproduce, which pass on those good traits to the next generation. Because of this, species can evolve over long periods of time to have traits that weren't common, or even present, before.
Do you think evolution is a fact or theory?:
I believe that evolution is a theory. There is no way to have 'proof' of it, or to actually see it happening. That is why evolution can not become anything other than a theory. However, nothing else in science really makes sense if evolution did not occur. Therefore, I like to think of evolution as a fact. Even if some of the details of how it works are wrong, it has to be the reason behind the diverse and ever-changing planet we live on. Many scientists have accepted the theory of evolution, and it is widely taught to students that the events of evolution are true. It is just one explanation as to how humans have 'come from' monkeys or how different species of animals start. Even how animals moved onto land and how whale fossils have legs. Without the theory of evolution, scientists would have a very difficult time trying to figure out how all life came to be, and what it came from. Therefore, I like to think of evolution as a fact even though it is a theory because it is the only way so far that scientists have been able to understand how organisms can change so greatly over time.
Well done, Sarah!
ReplyDeleteHi Sarah, I really like your take on whether evolution is a fact or theory, because I think most people think they have to choose one or the other. I like how you stated arguments for why they both would be correct.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Grace! I tend to be kind of undecisive by nature, so I usually weigh my options pretty well. However, I actually had a little background with this question from high school!
DeleteHi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your thoughts! I too liked how you approached the fact/theory section. It seems as though we can almost undeniably prove that there are significant changes occurring, but that the mechanisms by which they occur are not as substantial.
Hi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteBefore our Tuesday's discussion, I've only thought of evolution to be a fact because I was telling myself "well it has to be a fact because we see the details, and we see the changes through time." But after our Tuesday's discussion, I realized I came to a rashly conclusion with evolution being a fact when it can actually be considered a fact or theory. I like how you had an argument for both sides. I'll have give my future prompts some more thought with a mindset like yours.
The discussions are definitely a great way to see things from a different angle! I know that my eyes were opened in my breakout group, and the main group helped a lot too!
Delete